Tag Archives: racism

“Why won’t Rangers sign a Catholic?”

“Why won’t Rangers sign a Catholic?”

Posted on by • Posted in HR Thoughts • Tagged , , , , • Leave a comment

Is it possible to have a blanket ban on employing people from a particular country? That question came up last week when it was reported that Indian owned franchises in Cricket’s summer tournament The Hundred would not recruit Pakistani players due to the ongoing political tensions between the two countries.

Under the Equality Act, it is not allowed to discriminate on ‘colour, nationality, or ethnic or national origins”. And as UK employers, the different teams are bound by UK employment law. So how can the alleged ban be legal?

UK employment law protects anyone eligible to work in the UK – this includes not only UK citizens, but citizens of Ireland, anyone with ‘indefinite leave to remain’ and anyone working here with a valid work visa. Sportspeople in the UK are employees like anyone else and are normally here on International Sportsperson Visas.

When it comes to recruitment, an employer is not obliged to consider candidates who are not eligible to work in the UK and they are not required to advertise in any specific location. So in that sense, cricket teams in the UK are not required to consider players from any country. However, The Hundred operates on an ‘auction’ system where players apply centrally and the different teams bid for the players they want. It’s been reported that a number of Pakistani players have put their names into the auction, so they are in effect job applicants who need to be treated in the same way as applicants from Australia, South Africa, West Indies etc.

In practice, this is all a theoretical argument. It is very difficult, if not impossible, for someone who is not eligible to work in the UK to make a claim via an Employment Tribunal. And even if they could, it would be open to a team to defend an individual claim on the basis that the player didn’t have the right skill set (they were a batter and the team wanted a fast bowler for example). If the player in question was a British player of Pakistani heritage, or someone with dual British/Pakistani nationality, the issue might be different however.

It’s a very unwise step to have a blanket ban on people of a specific nationality and doubly so for it to become widely known. Even if the teams in question can get away with it legally (which they probably can) there is the ethical question – especially in a sport which has faced serious accusations of racism in recent years. As the old saying goes “it takes 20 years to build a reputation and 5 minutes to destroy it”.

For younger readers, the title of this post refers to a blanket ban that Rangers FC in Glasgow had against employing Roman Catholics or signing Catholic players – a policy which was only ended, to some controversy, as recently as 1989.

A cricket match in progress featuring players in purple and black uniforms on a grassy field, with a stadium filled with spectators in the background.
Cricket, lovely cricket?

Cricket, lovely cricket?

Posted on by • Posted in HR Tips for Business and Charities • Tagged , , , , , • 1 Comment

One of the most difficult situations a business – small or large – can face is when an employee, or ex-employee, makes an allegation of discrimination. The natural, and understandable, reaction of many is to become defensive – but as the recent coverage of the issues raised by former cricketer Azeem Rafiq about Yorkshire Cricket Club have shown, it’s possible for an organisation to make a bad situation far worse. As one MP said, Yorkshire’s response to the allegations was a “Venn diagram of stupidity.”

I’m not going to comment on the Yorkshire situation (plenty of others have done that) but there are some key learning points for all companies to try to avoid the club’s many mistakes

  • Take any allegation seriously. If someone feels strongly enough to raise a formal complaint about racism/sexism or any other discriminatory behaviour, then you have a duty to follow it up, no matter how uncomfortable it might be.
  • If possible, have the allegations investigated independently. But don’t bring in lawyers to do it – approaching the issue as a way of avoiding tribunal claims or other litigation automatically means that the investigation is skewed.
  • Equally, don’t treat it as an exercise in reputation management. The role of an investigation is to decide if there is any substance to the allegations and make recommendations on how to resolve the situation, not to protect your business when it may have done something wrong
  • Don’t just make it about individuals. While in some cases the ‘rogue employee’ defence may be true, it’s unusual that they will have been able to get away with discriminatory behaviour unless others have tolerated or ignored it. As Azeem Rafiq pointed out in relation to events that happened in the presence of England captain Joe Root “Maybe he didn’t remember it, but it just shows the institution that a good man like him cannot remember those things” (my emphasis)
  • Don’t allow your own view of incidents to take precedence. It is sometimes suggested that  an individual is being ‘over-sensitive’ and if this is genuinely the case then there may be little substance to the allegations.  But what is ‘over-sensitive’ to you may be the culmination of a series of micro-aggressions to the individual – things which individually are not worth mentioning but which cumulatively result in a perception of discriminatory behaviour. This powerful video makes the point very effectively.
  • Take action on the findings – don’t brush them under the carpet. And this doesn’t just mean ‘sacking a perpetrator’ if deeper organisational issues are revealed.

Not dealing with matters invariably makes the situation far worse. And while your organisation may not end up all over the media or having to justify its actions to MPs, rest assured that the long term damage to it may be just as bad.

My thanks to Business Coach and Organisational Culture Specialist Lorna Leeson (@reallornaleeson) for some of the ideas and points featured in this post.